The Dáil Courts of the Black and Tan War

Posted by Jim on February 9, 2019

By eirigi


Republicans swept the board in the general election of 1918, consigning
the constitutional nationalist Irish Parliamentary Party to history.
The decisive electoral victory was also a clear declaration that people,
in their droves, had abandoned the minimalist demand of Home Rule and
now sought a Republic.  At the outset of 1919, what are often considered
to be the first shots of the Black and Tan War were fired by Dan Breen
and his comrades at Soloheadbeg, Co. Tipperary.

As armed actions intensified in the months that followed, the Dáil moved
to officially establish the Dáil Courts on 18 June 1919. The courts
began to function effectively towards the end of the year.  In North Co.
Dublin, Thomas Peppard, Intelligence Officer in the Fingal Brigade IRA,
later documented how “the courts were well supported by the people and
the British Petty Sessions Courts and suchlike were almost completely
deserted”.

Sean M. O’Duffy acted as Registrar for the Courts for the South City of
Dublin from their inception in 1919. He described how the courts were
held in various places, but particularly at 41 Parnell Square, and
“usually at night”.  Judges were appointed and plaintiffs, defendants
and witnesses called.  Many of those who were central to the day-to-day
running of the courts were IRA members and the risk of raids and capture
by the crown forces was constant.

According to O’Duffy, all types of offenders were brought before the
courts, including “dairymen who had put too much water in their milk
before delivery”.  Many of those convicted of more serious offences were
deported.  Most cases, however, dealt with “processes for civil bill” –
i.e. non-criminal claims by plaintiffs regarding finances or property
against the defending parties.

The courts in Dublin operated secretly at first, but by the time of the
Truce in 1921 they begun to operate openly. Their headquarters in the
city by then was at a premises on Wellington Quay. By late 1921,
O’Duffy was full-time organiser for the courts in south Dublin and
surrounding counties.  At that stage, the courts operated on a basis of
broad participation by different sectors of society.  In theory, at
least one TD, local Councillors, members of the republican movement
from Sinn Féin, the IRA and Cumann na mBan, as well as trade union
representatives, and a cleric of each denomination, were to take part
in a local court’s proceedings.

The courts were organised throughout the country at the parish,
district, circuit and supreme levels, depending on the seriousness of
the offence.  Some of the titles of these courts might jar with
republicans and other activists today.  For among the lineal descendants
of these courts in the Twenty-Six County state corruption and classism
is rife.  Nevertheless, the Republican Courts of 1919-21 fulfilled a
vital role during the Black and Tan War.

A memorandum issued by Austin Stack during the lifetime of the courts
strikes to the heart of their importance. Minister for Home Affairs in
the Dáil during the Black and Tan War, and later a member of the
anti-Treaty IRA during the Civil War, Stack instructed how:

“…when Republican Courts have been established … and they are in a
position to deal with all the cases coming before them, attention must
be turned to the enemy courts. They must be rigorously boycotted… any
person who takes part in the proceedings of an enemy Court … will be
deemed guilty of assisting the enemy in time of war”.

The idea was to first of all win the trust of the people by acting as
mediators of their daily, and often minor, legal troubles.  The second
objective was to remove a key pillar of the British state in Ireland,
namely the administration of “justice” at the local level.  The sense of
autonomy and grassroots democracy created by the Dáil Courts was vital
in maintaining a vibrant republican movement, which was ultimately able
to bring the British Empire to the negotiating table.  There is plenty
that we can learn today from the history of the Republican Court of a
century ago.